The Chronicles of Narnia really disappointed me this
weekend. We had high hopes, based on the trailer,
that the film would some sort of great epic and in the
end, the film just fell flat.
What was it missing? Jon Favreau. Zathura went so
much farther in establishing a believable kids fantasy
adventure. Zathura also did something that the
Chronicles did not. Within the first five minutes,
you understood who the kids were - i.e. what are there
strengths and quirks and what the pressure in their
life was. Chronicles only established the latter.
These British kids have a dad who is at war and they
are being shipped off to the country. I could not
find a single distinguishable character trait until
they put their crowns on at the end and the movie told
us what their character traits were. I never felt the
plight of these kids. I guess you had to read the
book, which I did not. And will not.
So I do have to give Walden Media credit for their
marketing. $67 million for an opening weekend is
terrific. Mr. Dobson and his Focus on the Family and
every Christian church in the country are touting this
as a great, Christian film. In my humble opinion,
this film is really no more Christian than Lord of the
Rings. Or Star Wars. Or the Star Trek where Spock
dies. The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the
few. This is a common story device in all literature
and film. The hero has to go through hell to save the
world. Someone dies only to rise again. The same
story appears in every religious mythology in one form
or another. There is nothing uniquely Christian about
the Chronicles of Narnia other than what people have
told us is uniquely Christian. An impartial observer
might disagree that there is any Christian content
whatsoever.
So Mel Gibsons Passion was criticized for its
portrayal of Jews. If you go along with the marketing
and Aslan is a thinly veiled symbol of Christ, then
his crucifixion scene has some real anti-Semitic
overtones. In the Passion, the Jews were at least
portrayed as people. In the Chronicles of Narnia, the
persecutors of Christ the Jews are portrayed as a
bunch of bloodthirsty creatures. Minotaur and
Cyclops. Warthogs. Angry dwarves. Not exactly an
everyone can be forgiven mentality. In the end,
Aslan resurrects all of the good creatures. None of
the bad creatures are saved. Doesnt seem very
Christian, but it is a worldview that I suppose most
Christian churches ascribe to. Be saved or die.